INSIGHT by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA)

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU’s financial markets regulator and supervisor, has published two articles, one outlining an approach to modelling the impact of asset price shocks from adverse scenarios involving climate-related risks, the other exploring the use of ESG controversies for the purpose of monitoring greenwashing risk.


| Risk article: Dynamic modelling of climate-related shocks in the fund sector

The article presents a methodological approach to modelling climate-related shocks in the fund sector, which includes dynamic impacts, such as inflows and outflows from investors and portfolio rebalancing by managers. The analysis focuses on the overall direction of these effects, finding that investor outflows can worsen falls in fund values following an initial shock.

Dynamic modelling of climate-related shocks in the fund sector is part of ESMA’s work in relation to its mandates in the area of climate stress testing. To anticipate the impact of climate-related shocks on the financial system, the European Commission has mandated the ESAs to perform regular climate change stress tests or scenario analyses and to develop methods, parameters and scenarios for supervisors to use in their own climate stress testing. In addition, the ESAs have a mandate to conduct a coordinated one-off climate change stress test across the financial sector in coordination with the European Central Bank (ECB) and the European Systemic Risk Board (ESRB), reporting results by 1Q25.


| Risk article: Financial impact of greenwashing controversies

The article highlights how data on ESG controversies can be useful to monitor potential reputational risks around greenwashing.  It also outlines the challenges involved in using such data. The number of greenwashing controversies involving large European firms increased between 2020 and 2021 and tended to be concentrated within a few firms belonging to three main sectors, including the financial sector. Growing public scrutiny highlights the importance of clear policy guidance by regulators and efforts by supervisors to ensure the credibility of sustainability-related claims.

The analysis on the financial impact of greenwashing controversies is important since the transition to a low-carbon economy requires trust in the commitment and ability of corporates companies to adapt their business operations to help deliver climate-related objectives. However, greenwashing risks undermine this trust by sapping consumer and investor confidence, underlining the importance of monitoring and tackling the problem.


| Webinar

ESMA is organising a public webinar on the articles’ findings. The webinar will be held online via Teams on 7 February 2024 from 11:00 to 12:00.

During the webinar, authors of the articles will have a presentation about the articles, which will be followed by a Q&A session.

Interested persons are welcome to register by 2 February 2024 using the registration link.

After the registration deadline ESMA will provide to the registered persons the Teams link for joining the webinar.


All opinions expressed are those of the author and/or quoted sources. is an independent and neutral platform dedicated to generating debate around ESG investing topics.